The Globe and Mail: Where are Bell's 'tangible benefits'?

Image from Jonathan McIntosh on Flickr

For whom does Bell toll? The Canadian consumer, apparently. More details have emerged on Bell's avoidance of paying obligatory 'tangible benefits' in their takeover of Astral. These tangible benefits are intended to be a key source of funding for Canadian programming, helping to support Canadian Music Week and the hiring of new teachers at the National Theatre School.

Bell wants to use $40M of the tangible benefits they owe to fund expansion and modernization of their subsidiary NorthwesTel into Canada's North. Having unsuccessfully argued against paying into tangible benefits in their acquisition of CTV last year, let's hope that the CRTC catches onto their scheme.

Join us in urging a restructuring of Big Telecom by sharing our citizen-centered action plan with your MP at http://openmedia.ca/plan/action-plan.

Article by Simon Houpt for The Globe & Mail:

Do business people intentionally give really boring names to really important things so that regular folk won’t notice when they’re being screwed? For years, nobody outside the finance community cared about abstract investment tools like derivatives and mortgage-backed securities – until we all ended up on the edge of apocalypse. Smart people have told me that whenever they hear the term “regulatory framework,” their brains automatically toggle to something else to prevent a bout of narcolepsy.

But stay with me here, because BCE Inc., the behemoth formerly known as Ma Bell, is trying to weasel out of paying tens of millions of dollars it owes into a system supporting homegrown artists and Canadian programming, and nobody’s going to pay attention because it’s all happening under a government-mandated scheme saddled with the dull label of “tangible benefits.” And the case offers a piquant portrait of the Canadian media industry’s cynicism, and its growing sense that it doesn’t have to answer to anyone except its shareholders.

First, a briefer: When one company in Canada buys a broadcasting licence from another, it has to pay a sort of tax, a percentage of the purchase price, toward the development of the entire system. This “tangible benefit” is supposed to help to offset the negative effect that the resulting industry consolidation has on our viewing and listening options. The idea is that since Shaw buying Global or Bell buying CTV translated into fewer broadcasting companies competing for programs, the extra money helps to offset the lower fees that producers can charge.

The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission requires companies buying television stations to put 10 per cent of the purchase price toward the development of TV-related programming. The figure for radio station purchases is 6 per cent, and it goes to initiatives such as the Radio Starmaker Fund, which provides marketing and promotional assistance for emerging musicians.

Since 1999, when the policy was introduced, hundreds of millions of dollars in tangible benefits have helped to support such things as Canadian Music Week, the hiring of new teachers at the National Theatre School and an annual native film and media arts festival. It’s now one of the key sources of funding for Canadian programming.

Which brings us to this week. On Tuesday, BCE-owned Bell Media announced the details of the $200-million tangible benefits package it is proposing to spend over 10 years as part of its $3.3-billion takeover of Astral Media. The promises include $60-million in radio benefits and $95.8-million toward what it calls onscreen benefits, which encompass everything from TV programming to film festival sponsorships.

But then there are two curious pools of money that fall under the TV category: $40-million for something it calls “Supporting Broadcasting’s Digital Future,” and $3.5-million toward mental-health awareness initiatives. Both are laudable and, on their face, uncontroversial. Who, after all, could argue with the good work Bell does with its Mental Health Initiative through its annual Bell Let’s Talk Day, even if that’s not really what the fund is supposed to support?

The $40-million cash for “broadcasting’s digital future” is also going to go toward a population desperately in need of support, Canadians in the North who are on the other side of this country’s infamous digital divide. (In most communities north of the 60th parallel, people are lucky if the local phone company, NorthwesTel, provides the equivalent of the hiccupy dial-up service that most of us had in the mid-1990s.)

But here’s the hitch: The CRTC had already told NorthwesTel, BCE’s wholly owned telecom subsidiary, to modernize its system, which it has failed to do despite years of $20-million annual subsidies from the commission. Last December, the CRTC even said it was “concerned that NorthwesTel’s shareholders have benefited ... to a far greater extent than its customers.” The $40-million attempt to self-deal is more of the same. Read more »

--
Read more at theglobeandmail.com

Tell the government that it's time to fix our broken telecom market - sign the Stop the Squeeze petition ».